Indħil fix-xogħol tal-Pulizija: Silta (4) mill-Inkjesta

Meta ġew illikjati r-rapporti tal-F.I.A.U., is-Sur Keith Schembri kien bagħat għas-Sur Abdilla u talbu l-opinjoni tiegħu dwarhom fejn jikkonċernaw lilu nnifsu, jiġifieri lis-Sur Keith Schembri. Is-Sur Abdilla xehed illi ltaqa’ ma’ Keith Schembri darbtejn u ddiskuta dawn ir-rapporti li kienu jolqtu lil Keith Schembri u l-laqgħat saru f’Kastilja. Dan juri li kien hemm indħil dirett u suspett mis-Sur Schembri fil-ħidma u fl-investigazzjoni tal-Pulizija dwar irrwol tiegħu fil-Panama Papers. Aġir li hu ferm ċensurabbli u anke illeċitu. Il-Pulizija kienu jafu illi l-kumpanija 17 Black kienet tappartjeni lil Yorgen Fenech, imprenditur kbir b’konnessjonijiet mill-qrib kemm ma’ politiċi ewlenin kif ukoll mac-Chief of Staff tal-Prim Ministru. Is-Sur Abdilla żvela wkoll li kien ġie deċiż illi jmorru jkellmu lil Fenech Portomaso iżda huma u sejrin hemmhekk ċempel lis-Sur Silvio Valletta u qalilhom biex iduru lura għaliex is-Sur Fenech dakinhar ma setax ikellimhom billi kien indispost. Ma kienux reġgħu marru ikellmuh u lanqas talbuh biex imur id-Depot tal-Pulizija ħalli jkellmuh.

(pp.292-3)

Meta xehed l-ex Deputat Kummissarju Silvio Valletta, qal lill-Bord illi huwa kien għadda r-rapporti kollha li kienu daħlu mill-F.I.A.U. lil Ian Abdilla. Meta ħareġ fil-media illi s-17 Black allegatament kien jappartjeni lis-Sur Fenech u illi din il-kumpannija allegatament kienet maħsuba biex tgħaddi flus lil Keith Schembri u lil Konrad Mizzi, huwa afferma illi dak li jiġi trasmess lill-Pulizija mill-F.I.A.U. kien biss intelliġenza. Il-Pulizija ma tkunx tista’ tużaha meta tiġi biex tarresta lil xi ħadd u jkollha bilfors tagħtih il-“full disclosure”. Din kienet ukoll it-tezi tas-Sur Ian Abdilla.

Is-Sur Silvio Valletta żvela fatt inkwetanti dwar l-inċident meta Ian Abdilla u uffiċjal ieħor kienu ser imorru jkellmu lil Yorgen Fenech f’Portomaso. Qal lill-Bord li kien ċempillu Keith Schembri, iċ-Chief of Staff tal-Prim Ministru u qallu “mela ser tmorru tkellmu lil Yorgen Fenech għaliex semplicement deher rapport fit-Times?” Il-Bord jispjega illi r-rapport li deher fil-ġurnal Times of Malta kien jirreferi għal fatt illi Yorgen Fenech kien is-sid ta’ 17 Black. Keith Schembri ċempel lill-Pulizija, speċifikatament lil Silvio Valletta u qallu biex jordna lil Ian Abdilla u lill-Pulizija l-oħrajn ma jmorrux ikellmu lil Yorgen Fenech biex jinvestigaw dan il-fatt.

Dan huwa kaz ċar ta’ intralċ minn Keith Schembri fuq l-operat tal-Pulizija. Fix-xhieda tiegħu Silvio Valletta l-ewwel qal illi dakinhar illi kienu sejrin ikellmu lil Yorgen Fenech, Ian Abdilla kien ċempillu u qallu illi ma kienux sejrin ikellmuh għaliex kien indispost. Madanakollu meta l-Bord irrilevalu illi Ian Abdilla u oħrajn kienu xehdu li kien hu, jiġifieri Silvio Valletta li kien qalilhom biex ma jmorrux ikellmu lil Yorgen Fenech peress li dakinhar kien indispost, is-Sur Valletta qal illi ma jiftakarx. Ftakar biss illi ċempillu Keith Schembri u qallu illi l-Pulizija ma kellhiex għalfejn tmur tkellem lil Yorgen Fenech għaliex deher artikolu fuq ġurnal.

(pp.298-9)

Dal-għodu ġie imħabbar liis-Sur Ian Abdilla ġie sospiż :

Ara rapport Malta Today, Illum u Times

Wara l-gwerra ċivili fil-PN

Għad m’hemm l-ebda ħjiel tat-tmiem tal-gwerra ċivili fil-PN. Din qed tagħmel ħafna ħsara, mhux biss lill-PN: fl-aħħar minn l-aħħar qed tagħmel il-ħsara lill-pajjiż kollu.

Kull wieħed miż-żewġ darbiet fejn ġie espress vot ta’ sfiduċja fil-Kap tal-PN Adrian Delia iwassal messaġġ politiku ċar li s’issa l-Kap tal-Opposizzjoni għad ma fehem xejn minnu. Meta Delia stqarr li l-vot ta’ sfuduċja espress mill-grupp parlamentari Nazzjonalista u iktar tard mill-Kumitat Eżekuttiv tal-PN ma kellhom l-ebda sinifikat partikolari, kien qed jesponi l-miżerja ta’ kredenzjali demokratiċi tiegħu kif ukoll kien qed jirrifletti l-immaturità politika tiegħu. Dan fl-aħħar m’għandux biss rifless fuq il-kredibilità ta’ Adrian Delia imma ukoll fuq dik tal-PN innifsu.

Il-gwerra ċivili fil-PN qed tisraq l-attenzjoni li presentement jixraq li tkun fuq materji oħra ta’ importanza kbira.  L-irkupru mill-impatti sostanzjali tal-pandemija  Covid-19 u t-tisħiħ tal-kapaċità ta’ Malta kontra l-korruzzjoni u l-ħasil tal-flus jeħtieġu ferm iktar attenzjoni u enerġija. Mhux biss mill-Gvern, imma anke mill-Opposizzjoni.

Jeħtieġ li niddiskutu fid-dettall pjan ta’ rkupru mill-pandemija Covid-19 li jinfirex fuq l-oqsma kollha effettwati: pjan li għandu jkun wieħed integrat ma’ strateġija li tindirizza t-tibdil fil-klima u dan fil-qafas tal-konklużjonijiet tas-summit ta’ Pariġi.  Alternattiva Demokratika diġà tat il-kontribut tagħha xi ġimgħat ilu permezz tal-pubblikazzjoni tar-rapport: Pjan Aħdar: Ġust u Sostenibbli.

Studju riċenti ta’ Deloitte li kien ikkummissjonat mill-Assoċjazzjoni tal-Lukandi u r-Restoranti (MHRA) jindika li l-industrija tat-turiżmu bdiet ġejja f’sensiha. Qed tirrealizza li l-irkupru mhux biss seħħ bil-mod, iżda bil-mod ħafna: iktar kajman milli qatt antiċipaw.   L-Air Malta irrevediet il-pjan kummerċjali tagħha u issa qed tantiċipa li teħtieġ madwar seba’ snin biex tkun f’posizzjoni li terġa’ tibda iġġorr l-istess numru ta’ passiġġiera li kienet iġġor qabel ma faqqgħet il-pandemija.  Dan kollu jwassal għal osservazzjoni waħda – evitata minn bosta – dwar kemm l-aspettattivi tal-industrija tat-turiżmu dwar l-irkupru tal-industrija mhumiex realistiċi.

Ikun ferm aħjar kieku napprofittaw ruħna mis-sitwazzjoni u nippjanaw aħjar biex l-industrija tat-turiżmu tissaħħaħ billi ma tibqax tiffoka fuq in-numri imma fuq il-kwalità tat-turist. Pjan ta’ din ix-xorta, bla dubju, jkun jista’ jindirizza l-impatti ambjentali negattivi sostanzjali tal-industrija b’mod effettiv. Il-Ministru tat-Turiżmu  Julia Portelli-Farrugia ma tantx tidher li taqbel ma dan, għax il-ħin kollu tredden bin-numri.

Il-Moneyval hu Kumitat tal-Kunsill ta’ l-Ewropa  magħmul minn esperti li jevalwaw miżuri kontra l-ħasil tal-flus u l-finanzjament tat-terroriżmu.  Hu grupp ta’ monitoraġġ permanenti bl-inkarigu li jara li l-istati membri tal-Kunsill ta’ l-Ewropa qed jieħdu l-miżuri meħtieġa u maqbula fuq livell internazzjonali.

Fl-aħħar rapport dwar Malta ippubblikat fl-2019 il-Moneyval, tagħmel 40 rakkomandazzjoni spjegati f’ 233 paġna. Rakkomandazzjonijiet dwar x’inhu meħtieġ li jsir.  Ir-riskji għal Malta huma ċari: għandna ekonomija li hi vulnerabbli ħafna primarjament minħabba d-daqs tagħha kif ukoll minħabba l-fatt li hi esposta ħafna għal dak kollu li jiġri barra minn xtutna.   Ir-rapport tal-Moneyval jemfasizza li r-remote gaming, per eżempju hu vulnerabbli ħafna għall-ħasil tal-flus u dan “due to the high number of customers, mainly non-resident, the high volume of transactions, the non-face-to-face nature of the business and the use of prepaid cards.”

Mhux biżżejjed li għandna liġijiet li huma ġeneralment liġijiet tajbin. Hemm ħtieġa qawwija ta’ riżorsi għax mingħajr r-riżorsi ma tista’ timplimenta xejn. Ix-xhieda riċenti tal-Assistant Kummissarju tal-Pulizija  Ian Abdilla fl-inkjesta pubblika dwar l-assassinju ta’  Daphne Caruana Galizia, ftit jiem wara li tneħħa mit-tmexxija tat-taqsima tar-reati ekonomiċi, jindika n-nuqqas ta’ impenn biex il-ħafna dikjarazzjonijiet li jsiru kontra l-ħasil tal-flus ikunu implimentati. Sfortunatament id-dikjarazzjonijiet u l-assigurazzjonijiet repetuti tal-Gvern mhumiex kredibbli.

Mhux aħjar l-Opposizzjoni tuża’ l-ħin tagħha dwar dan? Iktar ma jikkonkludu l-glied intern malajr, aħjar għal kulħadd. Hemm ħafna x’isir wara li  Adrian Delia jiġi f’sensieh u jaċċetta l-inevitabbli.

 

Ippubblikat fuq Illum: il-Ħadd 19 ta’ Lulju 2020

After the PN civil war

The civil war within the PN has no end in sight. This does not only inflict considerable damage on the PN: at the end of the day it damages the whole country.

The two instances of a vote of no confidence in PN leader Adrian Delia are clear political statements which unfortunately the Opposition leader has so far been incapable of deciphering. Labelling the no confidence votes expressed separately by the Opposition Parliamentary Group and the PN Executive Committee as being of no significance further dilutes Adrian Delia’s democratic credentials and reflects his political immaturity. This has a bearing not only on Delia’s credibility but also on that of the PN.

The PN civil war is diverting attention from more pressing issues. The recovery from the devastating impacts of Covid-19 and the strengthening of Malta’s capability in the fight against corruption and money laundering surely require more attention and energy. Not just from government but also from the opposition.

We need to discuss in depth a Covid-19 recovery plan which spans all areas and factors in climate change. Maltese Greens have already made their contribution through the report published some weeks ago entitled: Green Plan: Fair and Sustainable.

A recent Deloitte study commissioned by the Malta Hotels and Restaurants Association (MHRA) indicates that the tourism industry is coming to its senses and realising that the recovery is slow, maybe even much slower than originally perceived.  Air Malta’s revised business plan is envisaging that it will take around seven years for the national carrier to return to pre-Covid-19 capacity. All this begs the question, so far avoided, as to whether the expectations of the tourism industry of attaining full recovery are realistic.

Would it not be more realistic if we realise that this is the appropriate time to plan for a tourism industry that foregoes quantity and focuses on quality? Such a course of action would address the substantial negative environmental impacts of the tourism industry. Tourism Minister Julia Portelli-Farrugia is not on the same page. She is unfortunately desperately after numbers.

Moneyval is a Council of Europe Committee of Experts on the Evaluation of Anti-Money Laundering Measures and the Financing of Terrorism. It is a permanent monitoring body tasked with assessing compliance of Council of Europe member States with international standards.

In its 2019 report on Malta, Moneyval, in a 233-page report, made 40 recommendations on measures which need to be taken. The risks are clear: our economy is highly vulnerable to money laundering, even as a consequence of its size and international exposure.  The report emphasises that remote gaming, for example, is inherently vulnerable to money laundering “due to the high number of customers, mainly non-resident, the high volume of transactions, the non-face-to-face nature of the business and the use of prepaid cards.”

Having good laws is not sufficient. Resources are desperately needed as otherwise laws cannot be implemented. The recent testimony of Police Assistant Commissioner Ian Abdilla in the ongoing public inquiry on the assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia, a few days after being unceremoniously removed from leading the Economic Crimes Unit, clearly indicates the lack of commitment to implement Malta’s declared objectives in addressing money-laundering. Unfortunately, government’s repeated declarations and assurances are not credible.

Some food for thought for the Parliamentary Opposition: the sooner they conclude their in-fighting the better. There is much to be done after Adrian Delia comes to his senses and accepts the inevitable.

Published in The Malta Independent on Sunday : 19 July 2020